Another humbling book. Sometimes, when I look at some of
the people that have reached the pinnacle of this sport/hobby/obsession,
and I compare their work with my measly efforts - well, it makes me
think I should toss the ol' Renzetti into the dumpster.
Still, we press on...
Anyway, what a book. Pretty much anything you would want to know
about Salmon Fly fishing, as well as Salmon Fly tying, is in this book.
Because it's written by Bates (or, the Bateses) it's quite readable.
It's not really an index or encyclopedia like the Frodin book, and
certainly not a technique manual like the Radencich book. It's more of a
general history of salmon fishing, that goes into some really deep
detail on the flies.
That being said, there are plenty of chapters on other stuff. There
are chapters on Rivers, on Tackle, on Fishing (both floating and sinking
lines have their own chapters). All about knots, casting, presentation.
There are chapters on various locations - North America, the British
Isles, Iceland, Europe. And each of these chapters is infused with
dozens of outstanding photos, drawings, and paintings. As an example,
it's not enough to have a photo or two of say, the Green Highlander.
There's a complete page of flies tied by a variety of tyers, in
different styles, as well as the recipe and history. A very
comprehensive resource.
As another way to describe the breadth of the work done by Ms. Bates
and her father, the end of the book lists a page of "Fly Dressers
Represented." This is a list of 4 columns of 140 fly dressers,
ranging all the way back to Pryce-Tannatt. A veritable "Who's
Who" in salmon fly tying. Very impressive.
So, not really a resource if you want to learn how to tie, but if you
are interested in different dialects of a given pattern, or the history
of the pattern, or the history of the art itself - this book is
invaluable.
[Seems to be out of print. Used copies are available from
$75 - 100. ]